Most Comfortable Bike Seat For Men | Women | Overweight People – Comfort Bicycle Saddle Reviews & Buying Guide
If you ask cyclists, especially the ones who recently started, what is the one thing they hate about this other than amicable and refreshing sport, even a pro rider would say that the saddle soreness and pain.
There is nothing worse than feeling discomfort in your nether area after riding your bike. While the issue is serious, the solitary solution to this grave problem is pretty simple: Buy yourself a good bicycle seat.
Bike seats can be intimating to choose from, once you know not all saddles are the same and not all seats will be comfortable for you.
To save you time, scare and confusion, we have reviewed the 5 most comfortable bike seats. At the end of the article, we have presented an in-depth buying guide to help you understand how to choose a premium quality bike saddle.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made through links in this post at no extra cost to you.
- 5 Most Comfortable Bike Seat Reviews
- ISM PR 3.0 Noseless Saddle (For Competitive Men)
- Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle (For Large Men and Women)
- YLG Oversized Comfort Bike Seat (Comfortable for Large Women)
- ERGO The Seat by Lycra Gel Saddle (For Relaxed Riding)
- Schwinn Comfort Bike Seat (Universal and Affordable)
- Comfortable Bicycle Seat Buying Guide
- Frequently Asked Questions
5 Most Comfortable Bike Seat Reviews
In this section, we’ll talk about the 5 most comfortable bike seats available in the market. Choose the one you find best for you.
ISM PR 3.0 Noseless Saddle (For Competitive Men)
If you don’t want to feel all that pressure and numbness around your pelvic region when you are fully focused on time trialing, the ISM PR 3.0 saddle is the one for you. You will get the world’s clearance for your hamstring and inner thighs with this one. ISM has been naming its products based on the shape, with this one being PR, or performance narrow.
What makes it so popular in the triathlon communities is the level of comfort the bike seat offers. With 60 series rated foam and gel padding, and a pretty wide saddle seat, you can take this out even if you plan to race or a city, mountain bikes, or hybrid and flat bar road bikes.
Moreover, the split noseless design with a space in the middle, this saddle, according to its users, does disappear under you. If you love to take the aero position, the PR 3.0 will give you support from a wider rear section and a long middle split. The design allows for easy hip rotation along with more vigorous positions.
A lot of riders don’t go for it even after all this praise and reputation only because it looks strange. Also, compared to other saddles, this is heavier. All that is easy to ignore once a buyer feels how the PR 3.0 has taken away all the pain and numbness around the soft tissue areas.
All we can say is that once you’ve experienced ISM’s PR noseless saddle, you’ll know why we have picked this as one of the most comfortable bike seats. Bonus, its great value for what you’ll pay and it is proven to be as comfortable for both men and women.
- 60 series foam and gel padding
- 145mm wide saddle
- Satin Steel rails
- Outspread rear part
- Rear transition hook
- Unisex product
- No pressure on genital areas
- Maximum comfort
- Great value for money
- Does not look appealing
- Bulkier than other saddles
Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle (For Large Men and Women)
The Cloud-9 Cruiser Saddle was specially designed for people who suffer from groin pain or prostate pain and targets the overweight cyclists out there.
The intense comfort level on this seating is achieved with memory foam that is multi-staged, accompanied by a gel padding system. The discomfort relief, on the other hand, comes from a specialized anatomic relief area on the saddle that allows blood to flow freely in the biker’s pelvic region.
Considered one of the most comfortable bike seats for overweight people, the linear design and wide back make sure your thighs get plenty of room and protection from contact with the seat. Few riders, nevertheless, have grumbled about abrasion on their thighs in some positions, although such a problem is eliminated if they tilt forward slightly.
When you are riding through more turbulent roads, the metal suspension along with steel construction absorbs most of the vibrations for a smooth ride. All tested and approved, this Cloud 9 bike seat is unisex, and can be taken out during rain or storm, without worrying about wear-outs. Additionally, you can fit it into your mountain or exercise bikes as well
If you taller and have thicker thighs that need more supple padding than others, this narrow, slit-back cruiser seat could save you from rasping and hurting your privates.
- Multi-level foam seat and gel padding
- Middle cut out and narrow design
- Open anatomic relief section
- Wide rear of the saddle
- Premium stitching on saddle
- Metal suspension
- Protective covering added
- Water and weather resistant seat
- Durable stitching
- Incredible comfort
- Shock-absorbing suspension
- Can be used by both overweight men and women
- Seat may rub against inner thighs when the ride is not tilted forwards
YLG Oversized Comfort Bike Seat (Comfortable for Large Women)
If you are tired of the seat pains that narrow, elongated saddles give, you don’t have to think about locking your bike in the garage. YLG’s Oversized Bike Seat is a bike saddle for women that is so enormous in size, they call it “oversized”.
The high-density foam inside this generously sized seat promises that your hour-long ride will feel like a minute. The support is fully amplified by the wider arc shape. This not only provides a greater butt base but also makes sure your hips and thighs feel no pain or pressure during the ride.
Larger women, who are looking to shed few extra pounds love the roomy support. For other riders who have used this comfortable saddle, they claim that the product fits almost any bike easily and it took them a few minutes to install. Moreover, the design has focused on safety more than other seats, with reflective tape at the rear.
One of the notable traits that we love is the double ball suspension made of rubber. This absorbs all the shocks and jerks to make the ride smooth as silk. Since a good suspension on saddles is not a common find, YLG has excelled in making one of the most comfortable bike seats for larger women with added security and stability.
- Huge size seat
- Universal fit
- Reflective tape
- Elastic memory foam and gel padding
- Wider rear support
- Double rubber ball suspension
- PVC leather cover
- Spacious support
- Easy installation
- Weather and damage resistant
- Vibration absorbent features
- Added rear security
- Lean bikers may face some issue with certain leg movements
ERGO The Seat by Lycra Gel Saddle (For Relaxed Riding)
On our list of top 5 most comfortable bike saddles, we have included few products that cater to riders who cannot choose any bike they want due to pain, joint, or weight issue. Ergo Gel Saddle from Lycra is a comfortable saddle designed for relaxed riding is a great choice for people who struggle with prostrate problems but want to go for a bike ride. Although this seat is made with women’s comfort in mind, the saddle can be used by men as well.
Despite its funny-looking appearance, the hornless design has premium soft gel padding which is Lycra covered and can take on quite high weights, even though the saddle itself is light. Additionally, the sit-bones seating helps to ease pressure from your genital area and inner thighs.
Although it is not as long-lasting as some of its competitors, this seat saddle is easy to install on most bikes. Few riders have claimed to ride across the country sitting on this very saddle. All thanks to its ability to take off pressure from the perineum and shifting it to the sit bones.
We should also remind you that the Ergo seat is usually not good for off-road biking. It is only reliable and stable when it comes to riding on smooth terrains.
- Sit bone seating system
- No horns saddle
- Back reflectors added
- Lycra enveloped gel padding
- High load capacity
- Universal fit
- Great comfort from high-quality padding
- Fits most bikes without hassle
- Installation process is simple
- Minimizes pressure and pain on inners
- Not bulky
- Can be used by both men and women
- Not as durable as other saddles
- Not for gravel surfaces
Schwinn Comfort Bike Seat (Universal and Affordable)
If you are looking for a good quality saddle without creating a hole in your pockets, Scwinn’s Comfort Bike Seat could be what you are looking for. This product is designed to fit most bikes you can think of, and can be used by both men and women. Adding more to its versatility, the seat is proper for outdoor and indoor use.
Snow, rain, or fog, the seat is covered in weather-resistant fabric, making it suitable for outdoor use, slightly more. The covers are also breathable, meaning when the weather is too hot; the seats don’t get heated up easily. Besides, if you want to go for a night spin, the incorporated reflectors will help you see clearly in the dark. Be cautious with the saddle though, it is not as robust and tends to bend or brake sometimes.
The wide base design increased the stability of the seat, assisted by the dual springs that absorb shocks when a rider decides to take the choppier roads. We also love the gel foam padding that provides extra comfort. The combination further allows the athlete to enjoy great maneuverability of the legs, without the things getting abrased.
- High density foam padding
- Maximum capacity: 300 lbs.
- Integrated rear reflectors
- Shock absorbing elastic spring
- Permeable and high-quality cover
- Weather resistant
- Budget friendly
- Versatile use
- Simple installation
- Jolt absorbing spring
- Optimum comfort and stability
- Saddle is not very sturdy
Comfortable Bicycle Seat Buying Guide
Bicycle saddles must be comfortable. They must also be a lot of other things. The different types, shapes, and sizes can confuse anybody, even the most expert of buyers. Read on to know what factors you must consider ensuring that the saddle you choose is worth every penny.
Your preference should match several essential factors that are necessary to consider.
Type of Riding
The type of saddle that would be more suitable for you, would largely depend on what kind of riding you do. If you are riding on mountains, the leg movement is frequent and varying.
You may have to be on foot on pedals or duck down to lower your body. Such riding requires saddles with premium cover fabric and sit bone foam padding. Faired shapes are also more preferable for such riders.
If you are into road bicycle racing and cover long distances, saddles with less padding are best for you. The shape that road bikers prefer is long and tapered along. Somewhere between these two ridings, would be seated suitable for bicycle touring.
Since such tours can last for days to months, high-quality padding for your sit bones is necessary with a prolonged and narrow shape of the saddle.
If your rides are short and non-sporty, and you ride a commuter bike or cruiser, you should get a seat that is suitable for recreational cycling. These saddles should have a shorter front shape, good quality padding, and wide rear.
If you want a seat for your bike that can be used by both men and women, there are myriads of unisex options in the market. Even with the option available, a lot of people opt for gender-specific bicycle seats for the construction. If a saddle is specifically made for women, it will take into account the physiological differences like inner thigh lengths and hip width.
We always recommend customers focus on the quality of the product and look for the best-suited features. When it comes to the most comfortable bike seats, the price may vary greatly. While affordable bike saddles are excellent, they may be discredited on their features. With high-end saddles, high-quality covers and better stability are more assured additions.
Along with considering the aforementioned factors, there are some additional technical factors that you need to consider.
Bicycle Seat Rails
Seat clamps are attached to seat posts with the help of rails. The material used for rails can make a difference in the quality and cost of your bike seat.
While alloy is lightweight and cheap for rails compared to steel rails, alloy made rails are less durable than steel.
Carbon, on the converse, is used in high-end saddles and can be incredibly studry and stable material for rails. Still, carbon rails have an oval shape and do not fit nicely with a lot of bike clamps. Titanium rails add a similar cost to the overall saddle price and are lightweight and robust.
Bicycle Seat Cover Material
The upper layer of the seat cover can have effects on the durability, cost, and break-in time of the saddle. Covers are mainly made of 3 materials: Leather, synthetic, and cotton.
The most commonly used cover is made with synthetic fabrics. They are easy to maintain, and the light texture gives zero mechanical run in time when newly bought.
Leather is also used for covers in many saddles and makes for durable protection. Interestingly, leather covers are only a little discomforting at the beginning of use, but soon they fit flawlessly. The reason leather covers might be out of favor with few buyers is that they are not waterproof. In order to wash such seats, leather conditions will be needed.
Cotton covers are comfortable, have low break-in periods, and are pretty comfortable when settled. Moreover, they offer great leg activity.
Bicycle Seat Padding
About the case of cushioning, there is a misconception that the ability of a bicycle saddle’s comfort depends entirely on the padding. And there is a general idea that, the thicker the paddle, the comfier the sitting.
Although it can be true for certain new rides, thick padding is not always the answer. If you are someone who is looking to lose weight through cycling, high-grade padding can make a lot of difference.
For padding, most riders prefer either gel or foam cushioning and claim that they provide the maximum comfort to softer tissues when required. The shortcoming of gel padding, in comparison to foam padding, is that gel is more easily compressed than foam.
Between the two, foam padding is a more popular choice among riders. What’s better than foam is firm foam that is not easily dented or compressed down.
While new riders may consider cushioning of the saddle a must-have feature, numerous experienced or slender riders prefer no padding on their seats. These seats are well molded by the leather or cotton covers and become more “customized” on the process and over time.
This means the no padding seats suit the rider and their comfort way more than padded seating does. Moreover, if there is no padding, your seat is bound to stay cool even under the hot sun. That is why many cushion systems for saddles come with a breathable design.
Bicycle Seat Shape and Size
If one of these said factors can have an actual impact on the saddle’s comfort, it would be this once. While others may depend on the rider’s personal preference, this will be determined by what kind of ride you are going for.
Streamlined seats are best suited for aggressive rides, where you have to stand up or stoop low from time to time. Mountain bikers prefer longer seats, similar to road bikers.
But, riders who prefer to cycle longer distances in an upright posture, favor the more curved and broader saddles. Additionally, Slimmer bikers will be more comfortable with narrower seats, while larger bikers will find wide-arced seats more suitable.
Bicycle Seat Center Split or Relief Zones
Centre cut-outs or channels on saddles are a feature that we fancy for all bicycle seats, and so do most of the riders. The hollow middle relieves pressure from the genital tracts and guarantees proper blood flow when riders are on their way.
Cycling for long hours can cause great pain and discomfort to the rider’s perineum. The center cut-out shape is intended to protect this area of your body. That is also why some splits are longer than others.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do I need a customized bicycle seat?
When we ride a bike, we expect all the weight of our body to be on our sitting bones. With a lot of saddles, owning to the designs, the weight is shifted to the lower soft tissues instead. At times, the rider’s genitals suffer numbness, and great pressure from the stern seats, which prevent appropriate blood flow. This is where the right bike seat comes in to save you.
Can I take a bicycle seat for a test drive before purchasing one?
If the retailer you are buying from allows it, you can. A test ride with the seat on is a great way to test out whether you feel any hurt in the lower regions. If there is any distress, you would comprehend it’s not for you.
Also, keep in mind that it is not possible to understand the good or the bad of a seat by cycling on it for a few minutes. Make sure you test it out for at least an hour before reaching a decision.
Comfort is a matter of personal preference and so will be the choice of the most comfortable bike seat. You might love a cushioned seat and the squashy softness that doesn’t hurt your inner thighs. You might love a leather-covered, unpadded saddle.
Many people who ride around for recreation love the seats made for women, while most love the long splits and relive channels in the middle. There are too many options and many great brands, but at the end of it all, you’d know what ‘feels’ best for you and of course, you will have to test out the seat before you can finally decide.